Bluefish is a meaty fish that pairs best with full-bodied white wines such as Chardonnay, or crisp white wines like Sauvignon Blanc.  Fruity and tannin free reds such as Pinot Noir, Beajolais and Grenache are also excellent with Bluefish.

Best Wine with Bluefish

Chardonnay and Bluefish Pairings


Bluefish is a full-flavoured, fatty and meaty fish, and often enjoyed like a steak, much like tuna or salmon is.  Because of it’s a fuller flavoured fish, a full bodied Chardonnay that is oaky and buttery will work well.  A White Burgundy that has seen some oak will also make a lovely wine pairing with Bluefish.  Old-world wines, such as Burgundy are confusing to new wine drinkers, so unless you are experienced with wine, or looking to spread your wings, I’d recommend an oaked California Chardonnay.

The larger the Bluefish, the more pronounced the flavour, and Bluefish can reach about 30 pounds. In most instances, Bluefish will be between 3 and 5 pounds as they are more abundant in the sea, and they are a touch sweeter and milder than larger fish. Fishy flavours also come out the longer you wait to cook this fish, so plan on cooking it on the day you purchase it if possible (as Bluefish does not freeze well, and it deteriorates fast!).

Sauvignon Blanc & Grilled Bluefish Pairing


As Bluefish is so oily, it is usually baked, broiled, grilled, or roasted. Smaller Bluefish are sometimes fried, but larger fish are difficult to fry as they are too oily.
Sauvignon Blanc is a crisp white wine with lots of citrus and grapefruit notes, along with grassy notes that may come across as herbal. Sauvignon Blanc has enough body to stand up to the meatiness of Bluefish, while offering refreshing flavours that contrast and cut through the oily flavours of this fish.

Other white wines to considered are well structured and rich white wines with good acidity.  These wines include Verdicchio, Grüner Veltliner, Viognier, Dry Rosé, Marsanne, Roussanne, Soave, or Gewurztraminer.

Pinot Noir & Grilled Blue Fish Pairing


Light reds, such as a Pinot Noir will work excellent as well due to the acidity, and the lush red fruit flavours which balance everything out. Pinot Noir has a lovely earthiness that complements any smoky flavours your bluefish may have from from grilling or smoking.

Bluefish is a heavier fish, and extremely oily.  The oil in Bluefish can numb your taste receptors after a few bites, however, the zippy acidity in Pinot Noir quickly washes these oils away.

Sangiovese & Bluefish


Sangiovese also does well too due to the high acidity and fruity flavours of this red wine.  Sangiovese is medium-bodied in terms of tannin, so it has just enough to hold up to the meaty flavours of Bluefish without becoming overwhelmed.

If Italian wines confuse you, and you don’t know the first thing about Sangiovese wines, look for a Chianti Classico.  Chianti is a classic Sangiovese based red wine from Italy that has been popular in North America since the seventies.  At the height of its popularity in the 80s, Italy couldn’t keep up and we were exported some rather terrible Chianti wines, ensuring Chianti fell out of popularity.  However, in recent decades, Chianti has redeemed itself, and most bottles imported into North America should be medium-bodied, balanced with acidity, fruity, and warm with herbal notes that taste like Italy (tomatoey, herbal, earthy and spicy.)

What Not to Pair with Bluefish

If there is a spicy sauce accompanying the Bluefish, stay away from red wines altogether, or else the combination will taste metallic in your mouth. Instead stick with Grüner Veltliner, Gewurztraminer or Riesling for any spicy sauces served with the dish.